AI Could Finally Push Law Firms Beyond the Billable Hour
October 28, 2026
Legal pricing is at a turning point, writes Peter Sacripanti of Broadfield Holdings for Bloomberg Law. In a recent article, he contends that law firms should replace hourly billing with prices negotiated in advance alongside clients, and that technology is making that change necessary.
Hourly billing accounts for the vast majority of legal spending in the United States, and it has been rewarding for firms. Rates have climbed faster than general inflation, and partner earnings have soared.
But automation is compressing the time many tasks take, so hours no longer reflect the value clients actually receive. Buyers of legal services are growing frustrated with steady price increases.
The author argues that hourly structures can pull firms away from their clients’ interests. Finance committees lock in rates, staffing decisions follow profitability targets, and stretched partners oversee junior-heavy teams, leaving work insufficiently reviewed. AI-generated errors that reach judges are one high-profile result of this dynamic.
Sacripanti compares the shift to streaming in music and television, where incumbents who tried to straddle models eventually lost ground to innovators.
Moving away from hourly billing is costly, since it demands new operating systems and tools that mine past matter data to scope and price work accurately.
Fixed pricing moves the risk of scope growth from the client to the firm, though discipline in time management and accountability remains essential. The author expects this transition to open new forms of value, and produce a fairer, more modern model.
Lawyers advising firms or corporate clients should view fiduciary duties as the anchor for this debate, since pricing should reflect the client’s interests.
Outside counsel spend becomes more predictable under fixed fees, which gives in-house teams leverage when negotiating engagements. Board governance matters because leaders must weigh short-term revenue loss against long-term positioning.
Enterprise risk management should address who bears the cost of scope creep and how quality review is maintained. Alternative dispute resolution clauses may also deserve attention in fixed-fee agreements.
Get the free newsletter
Subscribe for news, insights and thought leadership curated for the law firm audience.