Price the Work, Not the Timekeeper: The Better Way to Raise Rates

October 27, 2026

Price the Work, Not the Timekeeper: the Better Way to Raise Rates

Shireen Hilal is the founder and CEO of Maior, a consulting firm helping law firm leaders increase revenue and profitability, build new growth strategies, and stand out in a crowded market. Prior to Maior, Hilal practiced as a litigator at AmLaw50 firms and served as the COO of a national law firm. She can be reached at shireen@maiorconsultants.com.

This column answers law firm leaders’ questions by going straight to the source: the in-house counsel who hire, manage, and sometimes challenge them. Each piece starts with what clients are saying and ends with actionable insights on how your firm can win more outside counsel business. Past editions of the column can be found here.

Law firms are starting to set their 2027 rates, and the same questions come up every year: How much can we raise them? Where will clients push back? And will the increases we put on paper translate into higher collections?

Of course, hourly billing is not always the right model for the work, the client, or the firm. But where hourly rates are the starting point, the right questions to ask are where higher rates are supported by the value of the work, where they are not, and how those decisions affect both the client relationship and the firm’s bottom line.

Let’s look at how 2026 rate increases played out, what in-house counsel are saying, and how firms can set and communicate 2027 rates more effectively.

Rate increases vs collections

We’re closing out another year of significant rate increases. Through July 2026, average partner billing rates were up 5.6% over the prior year, the highest increase recorded by LexisNexis in over ten years. Associate rates rose even more, up 7.9%.

But as your firm already knows, increasing your rack rates doesn’t automatically increase collections. Thomson Reuters reports that realization has been declining since 2021 and, in 2025, a drop in collections realization was enough to wipe out the benefit of an additional increase in worked rates.

Point being, before increasing your rates this year, think about how much you’ll realistically collect and whether clients will respond by pushing back or sending work elsewhere. That’s where the in-house perspective is useful.

What your clients are saying

The in-house lawyers I spoke with were not opposed to rate increases across the board. What they considered “reasonable” depended on the nature of the work and the client’s circumstances, but a few themes came up repeatedly:

1. Not all work supports the same increase.

One general counsel put it simply: “Every problem has a different value proposition. There is no universal fee answer.”

Another made the distinction even more plainly: “We are willing to pay what it takes for bet-the-company issues, but when it comes to ‘getting the wash done,’ we watch every nickel and dime.”

Point being, the same client may be willing to pay more for a partner handling a high-stakes issue and push back hard on an increase for routine work. A firmwide percentage increase does not account for that difference, and firms should think more critically about how pricing should vary by work instead of timekeeper.

2. Have empathy.

One in-house lawyer explained: “This is so obvious that I’m reluctant to say it: pushing 7-9% fee increases to us when we’ve been through multiple rounds of layoffs means you’re not reading the room.” Another client described a similar experience after a particularly bad year. A firm they engaged to help them communicate losses to shareholders sent a rate-increase notice a few months later. He pointed out that “someone could have at least picked up the phone and talked to us about it first.”

3. Silence doesn’t mean the increase landed well.

Some clients have a large enough legal budget to negotiate aggressively. An in-house lawyer at a Fortune 50 company told me, “I don’t know anyone in-house that pays the rack rate. We negotiate or ask to pay last year’s rate.” But others feel they have less leverage. One general counsel of a privately held, luxury company explained that he has historically felt he had little leverage compared to larger peers. “The problem is getting a 10-15% discount after rates have already gone up 40% over three years only helps so much.” Importantly, the ones who accept the increase noted they may get pickier about the work they send out and who it doing it.

How to raise rates

Finance may set the firm’s overall rate target, but relationship partners should make client-level decisions so pricing makes sense for each type of work and each client. Too many firms apply blanket increases by class year or seniority, then leave relationship partners to deal with the pushback.

1. Price the work

A partner doing high-stakes regulatory work in legal gray areas may support a significant increase. Routine filings the client could easily move elsewhere may not. And where the firm can make commoditized work materially more efficient, there may be cases where lowering fees helps keep more of the work while preserving or improving profitability. Start with your largest and most important clients, and have relationship partners sit down with finance before rates are finalized to review the matter mix. Consider which matters require scarce expertise, which are repeatable, which are already heavily discounted, and which could easily be absorbed in-house or moved to another firm if the price jumps.

One in-house litigator explained that increases make more sense when the firm can point to what has changed: perhaps a firm has handled several matters for the client and the issues have become more complex, or a flat-fee arrangement requires more people than it did when the price was set. A shift from single-plaintiff matters to class actions, for example, is a much clearer reason for a higher price than simply another year passing. Raise rates where expertise, judgment, scarcity, or stakes support it, and hold or lower them where efficiency lets the firm deliver routine work profitably at a better price.

2. Price the circumstance

Your relationship partners should know what is happening in their clients’ businesses. Is the business growing? Cutting headcount? Holding its legal budget flat? Under pressure to reduce outside spend? Going through large-scale layoffs? You might still increase fees for a client under pressure, but that decision should be made consciously. The client’s circumstances extend beyond its financial performance.

Industry matters too. One general counsel in the sports industry described it as a “passion paycut” business: outside lawyers want the work because they want to be in sports, which gives clients more pricing leverage unless the work is highly specialized. The dynamic will be different in every industry, but relationship partners should understand the market around the client, not just the firm’s internal view of what its lawyers should cost. Finance can recommend the increase, but the relationship partner should be able to explain what’s happening with the industry and client and come to a logical decision.

 3. Make each hour worth more

One general counsel explained: “If you’re charging me 30% more than you did five years ago, I expect something for that.” Increased value can show up a few ways:

  • More accomplished in the same hours. If you’re preparing to defend the CEO for her deposition, you will likely still use the same amount of time given the stakes. But better technology, stronger institutional knowledge, and experience should help the lawyer get through more material, test more issues, and be better prepared in that same time.
  • Fewer hours for repeatable work. If your firm has been handling the same client’s contracts for years, you should already know its risk appetite, the terms it will accept, where it draws the line, and which issues matter most internally. Technology, prior work product, precedent, and experience should reduce the time spent relearning the client and recreating work you have already done.

Either way, the client should be able to see what changed. As rates rise, the hour should buy better judgment, more output, less relearning, smarter use of the team, or some combination of those things.

4. Manage your matters better

One in-house lawyer explained: “Sometimes an associate is great because they’re turning a draft overnight at half the partner’s rate, but for an issue of first impression, only a partner is valuable.” Point being, higher rates are easier to defend when the client can see that the right people are doing the right work and that the matter is being run with little avoidable waste. Things you can do to make the value of your rates unquestionable:

  • Staff at the right level. Review the last few bills. Is a partner doing work an associate could handle? Are multiple lawyers attending the same calls? Is the client paying for a junior lawyer to get up to speed every time the team changes? Is the firm recreating work it has already done for the same client?
  • Budget and assign the matter deliberately. For larger matters, decide from the outset who owns each part of the work, where senior judgment is worth paying for, where more junior lawyers can handle the execution, and what assumptions the budget is based on.
  • Make changes visible while the client can still act. The client should know who is doing what and why, how the matter is tracking against budget, and when the assumptions have changed. If scope moves, tell them while there is still time to make a decision, not when the bill arrives.

The client may still spend more, but the staffing, budget, and process should make clear why.

Communicating the increase

When you raise rates, explain what is changing and why.

For important clients, the relationship partner should have the conversation rather than rely on a generic notice from finance. If the client is having a difficult year, talk about the increase in that context, including where the firm may be able to help stretch the budget elsewhere. Also, if you know it may not land well, pick up the phone and don’t default to email.

Also give your clients a reason for the increase. One in-house lawyer explained that even market context can be persuasive: if a firm has looked at comparable firms and remains below market, explaining that the increase is intended to bring rates closer to peers gives the client useful context and reduces the instinct to shop the work elsewhere.

Then get to the point and call the increase what it is. Clients do not need a “pricing update” or a canned thank-you note before learning that their rates are going up. Be clear about the change, how it applies, and what they are getting for the higher price.

The bottom line

Your relationship partners should already be talking with clients at least once a year about their needs, budgets, what is working, and how the firm can serve them better. Rate increases should be part of that broader conversation about the relationship and the value the firm is providing, not a standalone announcement that shows up once a year. Consider treating this year’s rate-setting process as a client management, not a finance, exercise.

Get the free newsletter

Subscribe for news, insights and thought leadership curated for the law firm audience.